Skip Navigation
Edvisors Star Logo
Edvisors Logo
  • Compare Lenders
    • PRIVATE STUDENT LOANS
    • REFINANCE STUDENT LOANS

    featured articles

    • Best Private Student Loans for May 2025
    • Student Loan Comparison: Federal Loans vs Private Loans
    • Parent PLUS Loans vs Private Student Loans
    • How Does Interest on Student Loans Work?
    • Private Student Loan Cosigner: Everything you Need to Know
    • View All Articles >
    Earnest Private Student Loan

    Variable Rates: 4.99% - 16.85% APR1

    Fixed Rates: 3.47% - 16.49% APR1

    Apply Now

    featured articles

    • Compare Lenders
    • Best Student Loan Refinance Companies for May 2025
    • Federal Student Loan Repayment Plans
    • Student Loan Forgiveness: How to Get Student Loans Forgiven
    • Repayment Plans for Private Student Loans
    • Parent PLUS Loan Forgiveness
    • View All Articles >
    Earnest Private Student Loan

    Variable rates as low as: 5.88% APR (with Autopay)*

    Fixed rates as low as: 4.45% APR (with Autopay)*

    Apply Now
  • Scholarships
    • COLLEGE GRANTS
    • COLLEGE SCHOLARSHIPS
    • EMPLOYER
    • MILITARY

    featured articles

    • What's the difference between scholarships and grants?
    • Graduate Fellowships
    • View All Articles >
    Enter to Win $2,500 to Help Pay for College

    featured articles

    • How to Find Scholarships
    • Top Tips for Winning Scholarships for College
    • Apply for Free Scholarships for College
    • Most Popular Scholarships for College Students in 2025
    • View All Articles >
    Enter to Win $2,500 to Help Pay for College

    featured articles

    • What is Federal Work Study Program?
    • Employer Tuition Assistance Programs: How Do They Work?
    • View All Articles >
    Enter to Win $2,500 to Help Pay for College

    featured articles

    • GI Bill
    • Military Service Academies
    • ROTC Scholarships
    • View All Articles >
    Enter to Win $2,500 to Help Pay for College
  • Plan for College
    • CAREERS
    • COLLEGE ADMISSIONS
    • FAFSA
    • SCHOLARSHIPS
    • PAYING FOR COLLEGE
    • STUDENT LIFE BLOG

    featured articles

    • Best Job Search Sites May 2025
    • Resumes That Get Noticed
    • High Paying Careers
    • STEM Careers
    • View All Articles >
    Are you ready for college? You are with GradGuard

    featured articles

    • Measuring Academic Fit: Reach, Match and Safety Schools
    • Need-Blind Admissions
    • How Long is a College Essay
    • When are College Applications Due
    • How to Write a Good College Essay
    • View All Articles >
    Enter to Win $2,500 to Help Pay for College

    featured articles

    • Filing the FAFSA 2025-2026: A Simple Guide for Students
    • FAFSA Deadlines for 2025-2026
    • FAFSA FAQ - Your FAFSA Questions Answered
    • View All Articles >
    Enter to Win $2,500 to Help Pay for College

    featured articles

    • Most Popular Scholarships for College Students in 2025
    • Apply for Free Scholarships for College
    • College Scholarships for Kids
    • Most Prestigious Undergraduate Scholarships
    • Las mejores becas para estudiantes hispanos y latinos
    • View All Articles >
    Enter to Win $2,500 to Help Pay for College

    featured articles

    • How to Pay for College
    • Tuition Payment Plans
    • Pros and Cons: Borrowing From My 401K to Pay for College
    • Paying College Tuition with a Credit Card
    • Best Ways to Pay for College Without Financial Aid
    • View All Articles >
    Enter to Win $2,500 to Help Pay for College

    featured articles

    • Financial Aid Disbursement: When and How You Will Get It
    • Should I Pay Off My Student Loans Right Now
    • How to Minimize Student Loan Debt
    • View All Articles >
    Are you ready for college? You are with GradGuard
  • Student Loans
    • FAFSA
    • PRIVATE STUDENT LOANS
    • FEDERAL STUDENT LOANS
    • REPAY STUDENT LOANS
    • LENDER REVIEWS

    featured articles

    • Filing the FAFSA 2025-2026: A Simple Guide for Students
    • FAFSA FAQ - Your FAFSA Questions Answered
    • FAFSA Deadlines for 2025-2026
    • FAFSA School Codes
    • FAFSA 2023-2024 Guide & Resources
    • View All Articles >
    Earnest Private Student Loan

    Variable Rates: 4.99% - 16.85% APR1

    Fixed Rates: 3.47% - 16.49% APR1

    Apply Now

    featured articles

    • Best Private Student Loans for May 2025
    • Student Loan Comparison: Federal Loans vs Private Loans
    • Parent PLUS Loans vs Private Student Loans
    • How Does Interest on Student Loans Work?
    • Private Student Loan Cosigner: Everything you Need to Know
    • View All Articles >
    Earnest Private Student Loan

    Variable Rates: 4.99% - 16.85% APR1

    Fixed Rates: 3.47% - 16.49% APR1

    Apply Now

    featured articles

    • Filing the FAFSA 2025-2026: A Simple Guide for Students
    • FAFSA FAQ - Your FAFSA Questions Answered
    • The complete guide to federal undergraduate student loans
    • What are Federal Parent PLUS Loans and How to Apply
    • Financial Aid for Graduate School
    • Compare Subsidized and Unsubsidized Student Loans
    • View All Articles >
    Earnest Private Student Loan

    Variable Rates: 4.99% - 16.85% APR1

    Fixed Rates: 3.47% - 16.49% APR1

    Apply Now

    featured articles

    • Best Student Loan Refinance Companies for May 2025
    • Federal Student Loan Repayment Plans
    • Student Loan Forgiveness: How to Get Student Loans Forgiven
    • Repayment Plans for Private Student Loans
    • Should You Refinance Federal Student Loans?
    • Parent PLUS Loan Forgiveness
    • View All Articles >
    Enter the Repayment Relief Sweepstakes

    featured articles

    • Sallie Mae Student Loan Review
    • College Ave Student Loan Review
    • SoFi Student Loan Review
    • Ascent Student Loan Review
    • View All Articles >
    Earnest Private Student Loan

    Variable Rates: 4.99% - 16.85% APR1

    Fixed Rates: 3.47% - 16.49% APR1

    Apply Now
  • Credit Cards
    • CARD REVIEWS
    • BEST CREDIT CARDS
    • CREDIT CARD FAQS

    featured articles

    • Petal® 2 Visa® Credit Card Review
    Self Credit Builder: Build Credit. Build Savings. Build Dreams.

    featured articles

    • Best Credit Cards for 2025
    • Best Cash Back Credit Cards
    • Best 0% Introductory APR Credit Cards
    • Best Secured Credit Cards for 2025
    • Best Balance Transfer Credit Cards
    Self Credit Builder: Build Credit. Build Savings. Build Dreams.

    featured articles

    • How to Build Credit?
    • What Age Can You Get a Credit Card?
    • What is a Secured Credit Card?
    • What is an Unsecured Credit Card?
    Self Credit Builder: Build Credit. Build Savings. Build Dreams.
  • Money Management
    • BANKING
    • BUDGETING
    • SAVING
    • DEBT MANAGEMENT
    • CREDIT
    • INVESTING
    • RISK MANAGEMENT

    featured articles

    • What is Online Banking
    • Student Checking Accounts
    • Debit Cards with Rewards
    • View All Articles >
    Chase College Checking Visa Debit

    featured articles

    • Best Budgeting Apps May 2025
    • Budgeting Tips
    • Budgeting for Beginners
    • View All Articles >
    Change Your Relationship With Money

    featured articles

    • Financial Goals
    • How to Save Money as a College Student
    • What is an Emergency Fund
    • View All Articles >
    Change Your Relationship With Money

    featured articles

    • How to Pay Off Debt
    • Debt Relief
    • What is a Debt Management Plan
    • View All Articles >
    Change Your Relationship With Money

    featured articles

    • How to Check Your Credit Score
    • Best Credit Building Apps May 2025
    • What is Credit?
    • View All Articles >
    Self Credit Builder: Build Credit. Build Savings. Build Dreams.

    featured articles

    • Investing for Beginners
    • Best Investment Apps May 2025
    • Understanding the Stock Market
    • View All Articles >
    Change Your Relationship With Money

    featured articles

    • What is Risk Management
    • How to Prevent Identity Theft
    • What is Insurance
    • View All Articles >
    Change Your Relationship With Money
  • Student LIFE Blog
  • Compare Lenders
    • Private Student Loans
    • Refinance Student Loans
  • Scholarships
  • Plan for College
  • Student Loans
  • Credit Cards
  • Money Management
  • Student LIFE Blog
Login
Register
  • Dashboard
  • My Profile
  • Logout
Search Box Form
Win a $2,500 Scholarship
Need money for college? Enter our monthly scholarship sweepstakes.
Enter Now
Advertiser Disclosure
×

Edvisors (“Edvisors Network, Inc.”) provides independent advertising-supported platforms for consumers to search compare and apply for private student loans. Loan offers from participating lenders that appear on our websites are not affiliated with any college and/or universities, and there are no colleges and/or universities which endorse Edvisors’ products or services. Lender search results do not constitute an official college preferred lender list. Edvisors receives compensation from lenders that appear on this site. This compensation may impact the placement of where lenders appear on this site, for example, the order in which the lenders appear when included in a list. Not all lenders participate in our sites and lenders that do participate may not offer loans to every school.

Edvisors is not a lender and makes no representations or warranties about your eligibility for a particular loan or financial aid. Lenders are solely responsible for any and all credit decisions, loan approval and rates, terms and other costs of the loan offered and may vary based upon the lender you select. Please check with your school or lender directly for information related to your personal eligibility.

Edvisors has endeavored to provide accurate information. However, the results provided by lenders are for illustrative purposes only and accuracy is not guaranteed, as such, Edvisors assumes no responsibility for errors or omission in the information provided.

Advertiser Disclosure
×

Edvisors (“Edvisors Network, Inc.”) provides independent advertising-supported websites. The Edvisors websites’ goal is to provide relevant and helpful content and comparison tools to better assist consumers to search and compare financial products or services. The offers, products or services listed on our websites are from third-party advertisers or companies from which Edvisors receives compensation. This compensation may impact the placement of where products or advertisements appear on this site, for example, the order in which the products appear when included in a list. Not all providers participate in our sites and providers that do participate may not offer the entire suite of applicable credit cards or financial products provided by the provider or available in the marketplace.

Edvisors is not a lender and makes no representations or warranties about your eligibility for a particular credit card, financial product, or service. The third-party providers are solely responsible for any and all credit decisions, loan approval and rates. Terms and other costs of the credit card or financial product may vary based upon the provider you select. Not all consumers will qualify for the advertised rates and terms.

Edvisors does not purport to offer financial advice related to the purchase or sale of financial products or services. We are not an investment, brokerage, or financial advisory service. Information provided with respect to financial products and services are solely intended for educational purposes. In addition, we recognize each person may have unique and individualized financial needs and we recommend and encourage you to seek the expert advice of qualified professionals regarding your specific financial needs.

Edvisors has endeavored to provide accurate, up to date information. However, because credit card offers and financial products change frequently and do not originate with us, we recommend you check the offering provider for complete terms and conditions, rates, costs, and other fees. Providers do not commission, review or approve the information available on the site. Information provided on the site is for illustrative purposes only and accuracy is not guaranteed, as such, Edvisors assumes no responsibility for errors or omission in the information provided.

Except as expressly set forth in our Terms of Use, all representations and warranties regarding the information presented on our websites are disclaimed.

×
Get Your Free Guide to Filing the FAFSA Today!

Thank you for your interest in Edvisors' 2020-2021 Guide to Filing the FAFSA.

Please complete the form below to access your free copy.

Thank you! Click here to download your free FAFSA Guide.

I am a:

×
College knowledge starts here!

Enter your email below to receive your Student Loan Handbook from Edvisors.

Please check your email for the Student Loan Handbook.

After Navigation
Home » Blog » Government Proposes Changes to Federal PLUS Loan Credit Criteria
  • Contents
  • Current Regulations
  • Operational Changes
  • Proposed Regulations
  • Flaws in the Proposed Regulations
  • A Better Approach
  • Public Comments on Proposed Regulations

Government Proposes Changes to Federal PLUS Loan Credit Criteria

edvisors star logo
By Edvisors Network
August 13, 2014
Email This Article
Fill out the form below to send a copy of this article to your email.
By clicking "Submit" I have read and agree to the Edvisors' Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We strongly encourage you to read our Privacy Policy to understand how we use and share your information.
A copy of this article has been sent to your email.

The U.S. Department of Education is proposing to loosen the eligibility criteria for the PLUS Loan, after previously tightening them.

Current Regulations

To be eligible for a Parent PLUS Loan or a Grad PLUS Loan, the borrower must not have an adverse credit history. The term adverse credit history is defined in the current regulations as a borrower with a current delinquency of 90 or more days or certain derogatory events, such as bankruptcy discharge, foreclosure, repossession, tax lien, wage garnishment or default determination, within the last five years.

Operational Changes

In October 2011, the U.S. Department of Education added two new criteria that doubled the PLUS Loan denial rate. The additional criteria excluded borrowers who have an account in collections with a non-zero balance or who have an account that was charged off with a non-zero balance. The additions were made without notice to colleges as required by the Higher Education Act’s master calendar provisions. The additions also were not made according to the normal regulation-setting process, but instead were described as “operational changes” by the U.S. Department of Education.

But these changes cannot be considered operational changes, as they conflict with a plain-language reading of the existing regulations. The existing regulations would not have included language concerning write-offs of Title IV debt if any charge-offs were considered to be evidence of an adverse credit history. Likewise, the existing regulations would not have included language concerning default determinations if an account in collections were sufficient to consider a borrower as having an adverse credit history.

Proposed Regulations

To address the flawed process used to make these changes, the U.S. Department of Education is now taking the proper steps required to change federal regulations. The U.S. Department of Education just published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) that proposes new regulations after negotiating with various stakeholders concerning a draft of the new regulations.

The NPRM encodes the new criteria in the regulations, but limits them to debts with a total combined outstanding balance of more than $2,085 that have been placed in collections or charged off within the last two years. The $2,085 threshold will also apply to the 90-day delinquency criterion. This replaces a previous $500 threshold that was used during the appeals process, per the regulations at 34 CFR 685.200(c)(1)(vii)(D). The choice of the $2,085 threshold is arbitrary, based on the estimated median debt level for loans that are charged-off, in collection or 90+ days delinquent, rather than any definition of significant debt. Based on data from the 2011-12 National Postsecondary Student Aid Study (NPSAS), 94.3% of Federal Parent PLUS loan borrowers and 96.4% of Grad PLUS Loan borrowers borrow more than $2,085 in PLUS Loans per year.

The new regulations will also require loan counseling for borrowers who have an adverse credit history but successfully appeal a denial based on extenuating circumstances.

The U.S. Department of Education estimates that 370,000 of the 1.1 million loan applicants who were denied a PLUS Loan in 2012-13 would have been approved under the new criteria, increasing the number of annual PLUS Loan approvals by about a third to 1.5 million.

Flaws in the Proposed Regulations

Nevertheless, the new adverse credit criteria still suffer from serious flaws:

  • There is no evidence that these changes will reduce PLUS Loan default rates. So, the changes may be needlessly denying PLUS Loans to borrowers who are capable of repaying the loans.
  • The proposed regulations are backward-looking, considering only evidence of past financial difficulties. They do not consider any evidence of current or future ability to repay the debt, such as debt-to-income ratios, minimum income requirements or credit scores. So, the regulations may allow applicants who are incapable of repaying the loans to qualify for PLUS Loans.
  • The proposed regulations do not include any exceptions for medical debt, which generally does not affect the likelihood that a consumer will repay other debt.

These regulations will permit applicants who are clearly incapable of repaying debt, such as applicants with no income, to borrow from the Federal PLUS loan program. For example, analysis of data from the 2011-12 NPSAS demonstrates that Parent PLUS Loan borrowers with adjusted gross income (AGI) under $16,000 have a debt-service-to-income ratio greater than 15% and a debt-to-income ratio greater than 100% (1:1). These parents, who represent about 18% of Parent PLUS Loan borrowers, are borrowing more for just one child’s education than they can currently afford to repay. The parents are at very high risk of defaulting on the Parent PLUS Loans if their income doesn’t improve or someone else doesn’t help them with the loan payments. These borrowers will continue to be eligible for Parent PLUS Loans if the draft regulations become final.

A Better Approach

Parent PLUS Loan borrowers should borrow no more for all their children than they can afford to repay in ten years or by retirement, whichever comes first. If total Parent PLUS Loan debt is less than the parent’s annual income, the parent will be able to repay the loans in ten years or less. If retirement is only five years away, the parents should borrow half as much.

Parent eligibility for a Parent PLUS Loan should be modified to prevent borrowers from taking on unaffordable debt by using credit criteria that identify borrowers at high risk of default. Such borrowers can be identified by considering debt-to-income ratios and debt-service-to-income ratios. The eligibility criteria should also prevent borrowing by parents whose income is below the poverty line. Student financial aid to low-income students should be in the form of grants, not loans. College grants should be increased sufficiently to eliminate the need to borrow for students enrolled at in-state public colleges.

The U.S. Department of Education, however, argues that consideration of a borrower’s ability to repay would require an amendment to the Higher Education Act of 1965 because the word “history” in “adverse credit history” limits the consideration to past performance in repaying debt, not future ability to repay a specific level of debt. Yet, this is inconsistent with the regulations at 34 CFR 685.203(c), which permit a dependent student to qualify for additional unsubsidized Federal Stafford loan limits if the student’s parent is unable to repay the debt (e.g., if the student’s parent receives only public assistance or disability benefits). One can argue that the word “adverse” enables the use of forward-looking analyses of the credit history given the definition as “preventing success” (Oxford English Dictionary) in the same sense as “adversary” as opposed to being synonymous with “unfavorable” or “negative.”

Public Comments on Proposed Regulations

The public may comment on the proposed regulations at www.regulations.gov using Docket ID number ED-2014-OPE-0082 through September 8, 2014. To be most effective, public comments should contain substantive criticism of specific provisions of the proposed regulations, not just statements of support or opposition to the proposed regulations.

It is expected that the final regulations will be published by November 1, 2014 and will be effective on July 1, 2015.

Share

Edvisors Network

The Edvisors content team is dedicated to helping our users navigate the higher education financial landscape.

About Edvisors

For 20 years we have been known as one of the largest and most trusted resources to help you find your path to success. Everyone needs to find their own path, and we know that first-hand. Helping you reach your educational and financial goals without stress, is our mission. Let's face it, it may be unavoidable to borrow money, but there are ways to do it wisely, including making the right choices up front, as well as during repayment. If we can help you make an informed and careful decision, we consider that a good day in the office.

Find information on this site to help you plan and pay for college as well as manage your money with confidence.

Federal Government Releases Student Loan Delinquency Data Previous Article Blog Home Sallie Mae Reports How America Pays for College 2014 Next Article
Could You Be Saving More?
Subscribe to Edvisors' Student LIFE Newsletter to receive up-to-date financial aid information and advice, explore scholarship opportunities, loan repayment options, and learn expert strategies on how to plan and pay for college.
Newsletter Form
By clicking "Subscribe" I have read and agree to the Edvisors' Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We strongly encourage you to read our Privacy Policy to understand how we use and share your information.
Thank you for subscribing to our newsletter.
We care about your privacy

This website uses cookies to offer you the most relevant marketing and targeted advertisements which in some states may be considered a sale of your personal information. You may exercise your right to opt out by clicking on deny cookies. Please accept cookies for the optimal experience. You can withdraw or modify your consent for non-essential cookies at any time by visiting Cookie Settings page

This website uses cookies for targeted advertising which in some states may be considered a sale of your personal information. You may opt out by clicking on deny cookies. Please accept cookies for the optimal experience. You can change your consent for such cookies via the Cookie Settings page

Edvisors
  • About Us
  • Official Rules
  • Careers
  • Team
  • Testimonials
Resources
  • Blog
  • Newsletter
  • Tools and Calculators
  • Video Resources
  • Financial Terms Glossary
  • Site Map
Media
  • Edvisors In the News
  • Press
Contact Us
  • Help
  • Ask the Edvisor
  • Student Aid FAQ
  • Directions
Partners
  • Advertise
  • Become an Affiliate
  • Link to Us
Legal
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy
  • Consumer Health Privacy Notice
  • General Website Disclaimer
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Interest-Based Ads
  • Notice at Collection
  • Cookie Settings
  • Your Privacy Choices Your Privacy Choices Icon

Better Business Bureau logo

Edvisors provides expert advice on planning and paying for college. On Edvisors.com easily compare student loan lenders, learn how to apply for financial aid, and discover scholarships. Learn about federal and private student loans for students and parents, how and when to apply to college, and more!

Edvisors (“Edvisors Network, Inc.”) provides independent advertising-supported platforms for consumers to search compare and apply for private student loans. Loan offers from participating lenders that appear on our websites are not affiliated with any college and/or universities, and there are no colleges and/or universities which endorse Edvisors’ products or services. Lender search results do not constitute an official college preferred lender list. Edvisors receives compensation from lenders that appear on this site. This compensation may impact the placement of where lenders appear on this site, for example, the order in which the lenders appear when included in a list. Not all lenders participate in our sites and lenders that do participate may not offer loans to every school.

Edvisors is not a lender and makes no representations or warranties about your eligibility for a particular loan or financial aid. Lenders are solely responsible for any and all credit decisions, loan approval and rates, terms and other costs of the loan offered and may vary based upon the lender you select. Please check with your school or lender directly for information related to your personal eligibility.

Edvisors has endeavored to provide accurate information. However, the results provided by lenders are for illustrative purposes only and accuracy is not guaranteed, as such, Edvisors assumes no responsibility for errors or omission in the information provided.

Copyright © 1998-2025 by Edvisors Network, Inc. All rights reserved.

All other trademarks and service marks displayed on Edvisors Network, Inc. websites are the property of their respective owners.

Edvisors Network, Inc. 350 S. Rampart Blvd, Suite 200, Las Vegas, NV 89145

Copyright © 2025 by Edvisors.com. All rights reserved.